A whole region takes action towards safeguarding children from racism

There’s a long road to travel but as a determined start, Gwent Safeguarding Board has taken the bold step to commission us to do a small scale but significant piece of research into the experiences and non-reporting of racism in schools across the region. Our report was considered in Autumn 2023 and published in 2024 with a bold commitment to a regional action plan and a regional anti-racist steering group to be supported by DARPL. Within this work, the region can seriously consider their collective contribution to the Antiracist Wales Action Plan (ARWAP) for 2030. 

Numerous cases are described in our report which found racism to be “prevalent” in schools across the five local education authorities considered in Wales. The research included both staff and pupils. Adults who were local authority staff told us racism is so persistent in our schools that it is a ‘dripping tap’. The official report covers Newport, Caerphilly, Blaenau Gwent, Torfaen and Monmouthshire. A supply teacher described her experiences being laughed at for the clothes she wears to work: “As a woman who wears a hijab, I often have pupils laughing or name calling. I ignore it – it’s usual. I’m always wary when I go into a new school. I have never reported it to the head teacher – why would I?” 

Our report was commissioned by Gwent Safeguarding Board, which is a statutory body overseeing safeguarding of adults and children in its five local authorities, in response to concerns that racist incidents in schools are going unchallenged. Principal investigators Chantelle Haughton and Dr Susan Davis from Cardiff Metropolitan University established a diverse research team including Leon Andrews, John Fernandes, Batool Akmal and Gemma Maiorano. They spoke with 56 pupils as well as staff and parents at five primary and five secondary schools, covering both English and Welsh medium sectors and rural and urban areas. 

Adult respondents described prejudice in communities seeping into schools and a failure by many schools to adequately respond to reports of racism. In our report, we refer to a “tide of racism” in communities which schools alone can’t tackle. Although there were pockets of good practice in addressing and tackling racism, it is not the norm. Among racist incidents described by the children was one primary school pupil who reported: “When I was younger, it was dinner time and the older children (year fours) were laughing and calling me blackie – I forgot it though because I was little, and I am remembering it now. It’s now making me feel sad”. Another primary school pupil even denied being black and didn’t recognise being racially abused because they were now “reluctant to even acknowledge their own heritage/skin tone.”

The following ‘worrying exchange’ took place with a group of children in one primary taking part in the research: Child A: “Someone was racist to you” 

Child B: “Were they?” 

Child A: “They said you couldn’t be clever because you were Black.” 

Child B replied: “I’m not even Black.” 

Our report explains: “It was clear to the researcher, that Child B was from a Black Global Majority (BGM) background, and in this exchange, they were reluctant to even acknowledge their own heritage/skin tone. We believe that this was related to the thought of being the ‘victim’ of the incident and the complexities on how people define themselves in descriptions of skin tones.” 

In other cases, pupils described being called the “n word” or “p word”. Children and parents from the Roma community described experiencing racism in and out of school, being followed by security guards in shops and their children being excluded while pupils from other backgrounds involved in the same misdemeanour were not excluded. Parents at one primary school described racist incidents as “regular” and “normal” in their community and said there were areas where they felt unsafe. In one secondary school, none of the parents or pupils spoken to said they had experienced racist incidents. 

Our researchers found that although “some schools were trying hard to engage with supporting students and in negating racism /racist bullying”, pupils often said they didn’t report racism when it happened. Sometimes they did not report it because they said nothing was done and in other cases, children didn’t want to be called snitches or get friends into trouble. We found that local authorities and schools “are not competent, confident or consistent in dealing with racist incidents and standardised anti-racist professional learning is needed across the board. There must be a clear process/criterion for reporting and for dealing with racism / racist bullying’’. 

All five councils welcomed the report and its raft of recommendations, which include each local authority developing an action plan to tackle racism in schools as well as monitoring its progress. “This will now be done”, the board said. Gareth Jenkins, co-chair of Gwent Safeguarding Board, said the report confirmed concerns that racist incidents are under-reported in schools. He said: “racism should not be tolerated in our society and here in the Gwent region. There is a determination to lead the way in making it unacceptable on all levels in our schools.”

The report confirmed our concerns that incidents are under-reported and, more importantly, uncovered some of the reasons that might happen. The views expressed by the children, young people, and staff were sometimes extremely upsetting and always sobering. This is not about pointing fingers but about learning how things can be improved to ensure that our schools are safer and more inclusive for everyone. All five councils have welcomed the report and are united in that ambition. This report will help them to ensure that anti-racism is further embedded in the ethos of schools and in everything they do. 

The Gwent Safeguarding Board has taken this positive, determined step to commission a specific piece of research intent on hearing and action. This is a vital stepping stone to be spotlighted for lessons relevant pan Wales. Our research findings are heart wrenching to hear and feel and sadly, no surprise. There needs to be stronger pro-action to racism and racist incidents in local authorities and schools across Wales; deep-sustained professional learning through engagement with DARPL; support; new guidance; explicit data work and ongoing research. The research voices spotlight critical issues which are also prevalent in other areas across our country. Our future generations spoke courageously to our research team. They want educators and policymakers to take them seriously and to hear their experiences of racism. They want improvement in support, knowledge, communication and sanction. The brave participants in the research want their honesty, experience, ideas and voices to play a leading light in the step-change. They want to start to feel that something is being done. Let’s really hear, truly care and build a new legacy together. What are you doing in your leadership work to contribute to ARWAP 2030? How is your geographical area working together in planning and action?

DARPL is working with all 57 headteachers in Newport, all 33 headteachers in Torfaen and across different areas of Gwent for blanket support, challenge and expectation. The approach by leaders in the local authorities working in collaboration with DARPL has resulted in emerging and pioneering strength in anti-racist focused Strategic Equality Plans, School Improvement Plans and sustained professional learning through the DARPL CoP. This regional approach is significant and sets-out a potential blue-print for other regions to consider and contextualise across Wales and wider.

To the read the full report, follow the link: English Gwent Research “stepping-stone” to tackling racism in Wales – Gwent Safeguarding 

For further information about DARPL opportunities or for advice please email DARPL@Cardiffmet.ac.uk

by Chantelle Haughton, DARPL Founder

Share content