Reframing Picton: Making Wales’ Colonial History Accessible to Learners

In the winter of 2021 Amgueddfa Cymru removed a portrait of Thomas Picton from our ‘Heroes of Wales’ gallery in National Museum Cardiff. The decision to remove the portrait was made as part of Reframing Picton, which is a youth-led initiative involving Amgueddfa Cymru Producers and community partner the Sub Sahara Advisory Panel (SSAP).

Picton has previously been hailed as a public hero but is equally notorious for his cruel treatment of Black enslaved people and free people, and for sanctioning torture during his governance of Trinidad, from 1797-1803. The project team then went onto develop the Reframing Picton exhibit made up of three rooms the first holding ‘Spirited’ an installation by Laku Neg, an artist collective with Trinidadian heritage spread across the UK. Their installation explores a re-presentation of Luisa, Thisbe and Present, named victims of Picton’s brutal regime in Trinidad.

The second room holding ‘The Wound is a Portal’, new commission by Gesiye, a multi-disciplinary artist from Trinidad and Tobago. Consisting of a series of photos and a film that invited Black Trinidadians to participate in a healing offering that includes a series of tattoos and conversations around their connection to the land.

And the final room curated by youth-led project team involving the SSAP Youth Leadership Network and the Amgueddfa Cymru Producers, presenting a whole depiction of Picton’s legacy, by providing additional information and context about Picton’s legacy as Governor of Trinidad at the turn of the 19th century that was missing from the previous interpretation of the portrait.

“There might be misconceptions that Amgueddfa Cymru – Museum Wales and the Sub-Sahara Advisory Panel’s Youth Network seek to rewrite history with this project. However, that is far from the truth. Reframing Picton aims to rewrite our future by challenging the way we engage with history. The project enables us to widen the spotlight that has for many years hidden the darkness of Picton in all its full and truthful context. […]We hope this is the beginning of discovery to the many neglected voices that makes Wales a prosperous, globally responsible nation that brings communities together to thrive.”

Fadhili Maghiya, Director of the Sub Sahara Advisory Panel


We worked with teachers, learners, the artists and the young people to identify the main learning objectives for our schools programme. The New Curriculum for Wales, the teaching of Black History and the concept of Cynefin all informed our work. The workshop developed explored the history of British Colonialism and the Transatlantic Slave trade with Picton’s legacy that has a clear Welsh connection at its core.

As we began trailing the sessions, we identified numerous challenges; including capturing the necessary nuance and complexities of these histories in a way that is engaging and accessible for learners. Some learners were coming to us with no prior knowledge meaning we often needed to spend time in these sessions providing necessary context before students could engage in more self-led exploration of themes.

The resulting workshop is adapted according to the prior understanding and knowledge that learners bring to the session, which is determined during an ‘opinion line’ ice breaker activity. We wanted the learners to consider the different perspectives that the history could be told from, highlighting the oppressive power dynamics at play. During the workshops they develop their ability to critically engage with what they are being told and to think about how that may be different from the truth.

“Our learners had a great time, I know a lot of them had never stepped foot in the Museum before so it was a lot to take in. […] The way you delivered the session was incredible, the questions were great and really made the group think about the work in very different ways. Thank you all so much for helping and facilitating this session!”

(Catherine Angle, who brought students from Cardiff City Foundation’s Future Pathways course (16+) and students from Pencoedtre High School)

“This [installation] made me upset and sad for all of the black people who went through slavery“

(Mount Stuart Primary School learner

“This has been a really good start to our topic, the workshop has helped the children to think more critically and see things from different perspectives.”

(Evenlode Primary teacher, following Picton session at NMC)

The Reframing Picton Exhibits will be running until the 8th of January 2024 [TBC], so if you are interested in booking a session with us for your primary or secondary students , please contact educationmail@museumwales.ac.uk.

With my work at Amgueddfa-Cymru I want to connect with educators across Wales to support teachers in educating future generations in a way that begins to readdress colonial and racist power imbalances. Moreover, I see the work that I want to do with my colleagues in Learning across all our seven museums leading to us moving Amgueddfa-Cymru towards a future where racialised communities are represented and respected within the learning programmes that AC-NMW provide nationally.

I am looking to collaborate with both culturally relevant communities and teachers across Wales, so if you’d be interested in working with me to discuss and develop new learning offers or would like to know more about the work I am doing email me at Umulkhayr.mohamed@museumwales.ac.uk.

Share content